The single final is insufficient, and the two-leg final doesn’t reward the higher-seeded team for their regular-season performance. So why not combine the two?
Source: It’s time to introduce a two-legged MLS Cup – with a twist | Sport | The Guardian
The single final is insufficient, and the two-leg final doesn’t reward the higher-seeded team for their regular-season performance. So why not combine the two?
Source: It’s time to introduce a two-legged MLS Cup – with a twist | Sport | The Guardian
Most of the time, journalists are able to put aside personal sentiments in sports and just do their jobs. Most of the time.
Readers’ accusations of bias are usually wrong. I’ve been on a sports staff in which we were all accused of attending one or another of the local high schools, even though we all grew up elsewhere. That’s typical.
When I regularly covered MLS in my USA TODAY days, people assumed I was a D.C. United fan. I generally tried not to be, and I think I was successful. Sure, you’d prefer to have a playoff game to see without traveling, so it was in my own interest to see United make the final eight or 10 or 37 or however many teams get home playoff dates in MLS. But at every game I attended, I went to the visitors’ locker room. I wanted to know the whole league. I have more vivid memories of speaking with Landon Donovan and Jimmy Conrad than I have of talking with any D.C. United players.
And I had something less obvious tugging at me as a fan. Real Salt Lake represents one of my favorite places in the world, and for several years, they had two Duke grads in charge — Garth Lagerwey and Jason Kreis. I like Utah, I liked the team’s staff, and I liked the style of play. If RSL had faced DC in an MLS Cup final, I’m not sure which way I would’ve leaned.
I have other sports in which I’m content to be a fan and not a journalist. I had hockey-editing responsibility at USA TODAY for a couple of years, but since then, I’ve been able to be a Washington Capitals fan with my family. That means I really enjoy the regular season and then try to go into hiding in April.
My relationship with the Washington Spirit is unique. I wrote a book about their first season, and it certainly would’ve been better for book sales if they had (A) won a few games or (B) had something interesting to say about not winning a few games. It’s tempting to look back on that experience with a grimace and have no investment in how well they do.
But I can’t. I met too many great people in the process of writing that book. And the Spirit did a great job of getting out in the community — I’ve taken my kids to clinics and open practices, and I know people who’ve played or coached in their Super-Y youth system.
And that first season was a long run of calamities. No one deserved to go through all of that. Those players — and the staff and the incredible fans of the Spirit Squadron, who may be outnumbered by their Portland counterparts but more than hold their own in every other way — deserve some good fortune.
Not that I think fortunes ever even out in soccer. I’ve said it 100 times — soccer karma does not exist. I could break the WordPress servers with tales of woe from my youth soccer parenting and coaching experience, all of which makes me quite sympathetic to the 2013 Spirit (or the 2016 Breakers).
That said, two of my youth teams have won postseason tournaments after finishing near the bottom of the league. So I can also appreciate what Western New York did this year or what Sky Blue did in the 2009 WPS season. Sure, Seattle fans have a right to feel aggrieved by the eccentric NWSL schedule, which saw the Reign play Portland four times while the Flash beat up on the Breakers. But the Western New York youngsters put things together at the right time, and we reward that trait in American sports with good reason.
But I know that for every scrappy underdog that wins in the last minute, there’s a favorite that feels deflated.
And for those reasons, I’m glad I didn’t have to write anything in the immediate aftermath of Sunday’s NWSL final, in which the Spirit gave up a goal in time that should not have existed. (I’m sorry — who adds four minutes of stoppage time to a 15-minute extra time session unless an ambulance was called onto the field?)
The final proof that soccer karma does not exist — the three players who missed penalties for the Spirit were the three players who have been with the team since its dreadful start in 2013. That’s actually enough to make you think there is someone up there pulling the strings to determine who wins what, and it’s someone with a sick sense of humor.
Also, we in the D.C. metro area have suffered quite enough, thank you. We’d all like to get rid of our local NFL team’s mascot and owner, though we’re sick of transplants to the region showing us up every Sunday wearing their Giants and Eagles gear. (We get it. You’re jerks. Thanks for reminding us.) D.C. United won a lot of trophies before Seattle and Portland invented soccer, so no one remembers. The one really good team in the D.C. area over the past 10 years has been the Washington Capitals, where Oveckhin, Backstrom and Holtby will break your hearts right around the peak viewing time for the cherry blossoms.
So to have a heavily favored team like the Spirit, with so much talent that Jim Gabarra was desperately trying to invent the 5-5-3 formation to play everyone, lose in the fashion they did is simply the most D.C. thing that could ever happen.
And so I’m heartsick for Tori Huster, who has made my kids smile at clinics and open practices. And for Diana Matheson, who exemplifies the polite, intellectual Canadian but is also a fierce competitor. And for Ali Krieger, who hasn’t always been at her best in her Spirit tenure but shut up her critics with an excellent season and strong commitment to the team. And for Joanna Lohman, who persevered through several Dark Ages of women’s soccer and suited up once upon a time for D.C. United Women, the amateur forerunners of today’s Spirit.
I sometimes wonder why I put up with this sport. Sunday’s game was excruciating to watch. The ref called the game as if he were paid by the whistle or by the minute — some clear-cut instances in which the advantage principle should’ve applied were interrupted instead, and as much as I hate seeing refs let “physical” play go, some of Sunday’s calls were baffling. I also saw yet another painful youth soccer game. And this year, the soccer Twitterati took a hateful turn that made the promotion/relegation wingnuts seem like Zen masters by comparison.
But …
Well, I haven’t come up with anything yet. But I’m sure I will. I don’t know if I’ll continue to be a fixture in the Spirit press tent, but I’ll still be going to games. I’ve used my new Sirius XM subscription to listen to Jason Davis and Eric Wynalda today, and I’m watching somebody play a World Cup qualifier now. I’m not even sure who it is.
Maybe that’s not healthy. That’s OK.
Besides, the saving grace of being a long-suffering soccer fan is the knowledge that others are suffering with you. And maybe celebrating on occasion. Or at least commiserating.
It’s been a season of controversy, but Sunday’s NWSL final is a compelling matchup between a team of polished veterans and a bunch of scrappy youngsters
A few years ago at the NSCAA Convention, a prominent ACC men’s soccer coach gave a presentation on one of the hot topics of the year: “Development vs. Winning.”
With video, he shamed an opponent that beat his team with a long throw-in. At his program, of course, they teach proper development, not little tricks like that to win games.
A few days later, I saw someone score a Premier League goal off, you guessed it, a long throw-in. So I started to wonder what level of play was above the Premier League, because he’s apparently preparing his players for that.
Yesterday in Portland, Jessica McDonald’s long throw-in was a potent weapon for the Western New York Flash in its shocking 4-3 extra-time win over the Portland Thorns, eliminated the regular-season champion from the NWSL playoffs. The commentators marveled, and I’m sure some purists howled.
Surely no one would tell youth coaches to ditch the “footskills” emphasis and start training U-9s to turn their arms into trebuchets. But beyond the youth level, long throw-ins are simply part of the game.
And it’s not as if the Thorns play on a narrow field — at least, not any more. We see some tiny fields in the NWSL and MLS (see NYCFC at Yankee Stadium), but this field is a substantial 75 yards wide unless someone ordered a surprise re-painting of the lines.
The Flash did a few unpalatable things to reach the final, abetted by a referee who either didn’t see or didn’t care about some of the jiu-jitsu Western New York employed to slow down the Thorns. Coach Paul Riley probably didn’t plan to be sent off, but his efforts to work the refs were certainly not in vain. And we could argue that it’s unfair for the Flash to be in the playoffs in the first place given Seattle’s much tougher schedule.
But long throw-ins are simply something all teams have to defend. The Washington Spirit surely will be aware of the danger when they face the Flash in the final.
The USOC Sports Scene is finally back after an Olympic/Paralympic break. Highlights from the prior week’s action include Brady Ellison’s fourth Archery World Cup Final victory. Consistency.
They don’t have much to offer by way of webcasts this week, though. They’ll have the men’s softball slow-pitch nationals, which is softball but is neither women’s nor fast-pitch and therefore not quite an Olympic sport.
What else is on? Frankly, not much. Silly me, launching this feature in the lull between the Summer Olympics and winter sports. But we did get some good news this week: beINSports has re-launched its apps — that’s particularly good news if you want to watch a ton of La Liga, Ligue 1 and Serie A.
All weekend
Curling: Yes, curling! Just in time for a couple of changes in the U.S. curling power rankings for men and women. The Stockholm Ladies Cup has no U.S. entries, but you can see Russia’s Anna Sidorova, Scotland’s Eve Muirhead, Canada’s Kaitlyn Lawes and a few good European and Asian teams. Check CurlingZone for the latest schedule. YouTube
Badminton: The Victor Korea Open has a few 2016 Olympic medalists and other top-10 players in the mix. Olympic Channel
Friday, Sept. 30
Soccer: Huge ACC men’s showdown between North Carolina and Syracuse. 7 p.m, ACC Digital (ESPN)
Saturday, Oct. 1
Soccer: Miss Newcastle United? Check them out in Championship play against Rotherham. 9:45 a.m., beINSports 4
Rugby: Watch New Zealand officially clinch The Rugby Championship, the Southern Hemisphere showdown for national teams. Again.
Ultimate: USA Ultimate semifinals. Go Truck Stop! All day, ESPN3 and USA Ultimate — event page has schedule (note Central Time)
Handball: In case you can’t get enough Barcelona, check out their handball team against THW Kiel in Champions League men’s play. Barca includes a couple of players from the Olympic silver medalist French national team. 1:30 p.m., beINSports 7
Sunday, Oct. 2
Ultimate: USA Ultimate finals.
Monday, Oct. 3
Tennis: WTA China Open, 2:30 a.m., ESPN3 (and other weekdays ahead)
And your sources for complete listings:
Carli Lloyd says she “doesn’t do drama.” And yet that’s her entire book. Indeed, it’s much of her career, and she devotes a lot of ink here toward rehashing the various reasons she has long played with a chip on her shoulder.
So, like prior books by Hope Solo and Abby Wambach, When Nobody Was Watching presents a more complicated — and more realistic — view of the athletes who sacrifice so much of themselves in pursuit of excellence.
Every soccer player starts as a recreational player. So rec leagues are important — and complicated, writes Beau Dure. They need to accommodate everyone from future pros to children with special needs. This week Beau offers up a comprehensive approach to making this entry level the most effective it can be.
The most controversial column I’ve ever written (yes, even more controversial than anything I’ve written on Hope Solo or the U.S. women’s labor dispute) was many years ago, when I took Manchester United to task for coming to the USA and playing a bunch of non-MLS teams. That’s standard practice today, but in those days, European powers would routinely play friendlies against the locals. Case in point: In 2001, the MetroStars beat a recently crowned European champion Bayern Munich side that was “tired from traveling and celebrating,” as Alex Yannis put it in The New York Times.
So in 2003, I was a little miffed that Man U was coming here — to play Club America, among others. I called them rude names. (Including, ironically given the Solo situation, “cowards.”)
The reaction was amusing. In those pre-Twitter days, the only real outlet for reader response was my email address, which was posted on the story. For the next few days, I would read scores of witty retorts in the morning. Then a bunch of profane nonsense in the afternoon. That’s because the actual English fans had a sense of humor about it. The American Man U fans did not.
Today, I wrote the second most controversial column I’ve ever written. I suggested it was too easy to bunker and counter in modern soccer, and I gave a few ideas for changing things up.
Now that I’ve applied ointment to all the burn wounds from a day’s worth of flaming, I can say this: Clearly, fans are content with the game the way it is now.
Mostly. Some people agreed with the idea of having more refs. Some even made a reasonable addendum: Get those extra refs on the field and then enforce the Laws as written. That, they say, will cut down on the negativity. Maybe so.
Some of the criticism was the usual “American idiot” stuff. But here’s the funny thing — you know all those Americanizations that the NASL tried (which, I said quite clearly, failed)? Go back and look at the history, and you’ll see it was the Englishmen pushing those things. Sometimes with FIFA’s blessing, sometimes not.
And there’s only so long I can apologize for the fact that the game’s called “soccer” here. In England, when “football” split into association football and Rugby football, association football was more popular, and so it won the name. American exceptionalism of the early 20th century led gridiron football to be more popular than soccer here, so the pointyball got the name. I have no earthly idea how “football” in Australia came to mean a frenetic 36-man scramble for a ball on a giant oval, so I’ll let that be.
But for most of today’s critics, the point is well-taken. Clashing styles is part of the game, and we don’t need drastic changes.
That’s great. I’m not wedded to those solutions, though the “more eyes on the field” idea is neither unique nor outlandish. I’m glad we had the discussion. Maybe the next time someone in the media complains about the entertainment value of a game, we can all point him to today’s comments and Tweets.
So is it safe for me to go back on Twitter yet?
I can’t find any curling, though I’ve updated the U.S. power rankings for men and women.
It’s not biathlon season yet. I couldn’t find anything on the Beach Volleyball World Tour.
But we press forward. All times ET.
Thursday, Sept. 15
Europa League Soccer: Panathinaikos vs. Ajax, ESPN3. In case the options on FS1 and FS2 aren’t quite enough for you. 2:55 p.m.
Saturday, Sept. 17
Cricket: Surrey vs. Warwickshire, ESPN3. This is the final of the Royal London One-Day Cup, which is not to be confused with Twenty20 (shorter) or the traditional county championship (longer). 5: 30 a.m.
Rugby: South Africa vs. New Zealand, ESPN3. The second half of the Rugby Championship double round-robin kicks off. New Zealand has a pretty wide lead in the standings. 3:35 a.m., followed by Argentina vs. Australia, ESPN3, 6:05 a.m.
Triathlon: Women’s World Triathlon Series Grand Final, Olympic Channel. The last race of the season-long world championship series, with dominant American Gwen Jorgensen actually trailing in the standings after skipping a couple of earlier races. 4:30 p.m.
NWSL Soccer: Boston vs. Western New York, YouTube. The visiting Flash just need a point to clinch a playoff spot. 7 p.m.
NASL Soccer: Indy Eleven vs. Miami FC, ESPN3. Two of the more ambitious clubs — one building a solid infrastructure, the other paying a ton of money to sign journeyman players — face off with third place on the line. 7:30 p.m.
Sunday, Sept. 18
Triathlon: Men’s World Triathlon Series Grand Final, Olympic Channel. Spain’s Mario Mola leads Britain’s Jonathan Brownlee. 4 p.m.
ONGOING
Paralympics: NBCSN will have a few hours a day, and NBC will pick up some action on the final day Sept. 18. Want more? Check TeamUSA.org and enjoy. Note the twice-daily highlight shows.
World Cup of Hockey: ESPN3 brings plenty of action from the sort-of national teams: USA, Russia, North America, Europe, Sweden …
And your sources for complete listings:
Abby Wambach has written a deep, dark (and occasionally funny) confessional that will challenge your perceptions of female athletes. Or athletes in general.
Source: Wambach’s ‘Forward’ a refreshing, insightful read which smashes stereotypes | FourFourTwo