soccer

WPS goalkeeping musical chairs

Chris Henderson (not the MLS veteran) follows women’s college soccer in rather remarkable detail, and I’m absolutely not qualified to question his selections in AWK’s 2012 WPS Mock Draft v1.0.

But one point is provocative: Would the Atlanta Beat make a colossal mistake by passing on heralded goalkeeping prospect Bianca Henninger?

A team’s goalkeeping needs may be more obvious than, say, a glaring gap at left wing. But goalkeepers are rarely in demand in the top few selections of the draft.

Check MLS: Out of the 120 top-10 picks of the past 12 years, only six have been goalkeepers. Brad Guzan was the highest pick, going No. 2 in 2005. Adin Brown was No. 3 in 2000. Steve Cronin has bounced between MLS and the second division since being picked No. 10 in 2004. The last three top-10 keepers — Chris Seitz (No. 4, 2007), Josh Lambo (No. 8, 2008) and Zac MacMath (No. 5, 2011) — were picked as prospects.

And that’s no surprise. Goalkeepers typically mature later than field players. We don’t have as much data in women’s soccer as we have in men’s soccer, but it’s safe to say we don’t see a lot of teen phenoms breaking through on the U.S. national team. Hope Solo debuted before age 20 but still wasn’t on the 2004 Olympic roster at age 23.

So if Atlanta is thinking of immediate improvement in goal, would Henninger be the pick? Or would the Beat look for someone who has already gone through the apprentice years?

With only five teams in the league (pending Dan Borislow’s legal action to get magicJack reinstated), you’d have to think goalkeepers would be available. The U.S. player pool lists five goalkeepers, so that’s one per team, right?

Well, no, it’s not that simple. But let’s take a quick look at the goalkeeping pool, focusing with the 13 goalkeepers who saw action in WPS last season. We’ll take into account that some keepers may miss time for the Olympics if the USA and/or Canada can qualify. And if a goalkeeper has retired or definitely isn’t in the mix for the team in question, her name isn’t in italics.

Boston: Has Alyssa Naeher (18 games in 2011) under contract after a successful offseason stint in Europe. Also re-signed backup Kati Jo Spisak, who started a couple of games in 2009 after sticking with the Washington Freedom from its W-League days. Naeher is in the U.S. pool but not in camp, so she’s not expected to miss time in 2012. They’re just looking for a third-stringer. Ashley Phillips played nine games for the Breakers in 2010 and remained on the roster last year along with 2010 third-round pick Kelsey Davis.

Western New York:Like Naeher, Ashlyn Harris (18 games) is in the U.S. pool but unlikely to miss time in 2012. The former Washington Freedom phenom is in U.S. camp, though, so she might get a shot in a friendly or two. She has re-signed for 2012. The Flash had two backups last year — FC Gold Pride alum Brittany Cameron and 2011 draft pick Ashleigh Bowers.

Sky Blue: The Jersey team has Karina LeBlanc (1 game, magicJack) under contract. The former Los Angeles Sol starter, who split time with Val Henderson in Philly in 2010, might miss time if Canada qualifies to the Olympics. Keeper/sweeper Jenni Branam has retired. The question mark is English starter Karen Bardsley (3 games), who played a lot for Sky Blue in 2010 but much less for the club last year due to World Cup duty and Branam’s play. Bardsley is likely to be in London with the one-off Great Britain team; would she want to spend part of the season in the USA? (Bardsley is indeed staying overseas, as Jenna at All White Kit points out.) Sky Blue carried two more keepers last year: Erin Guthrie, who has an FC Gold Pride appearance on her resume, and Kristin Arnold.

Philadelphia: Terrific tandem last year with two-year FC Gold Pride starter and veteran U.S. backup Nicole Barnhart (9 games) and former Los Angeles backup Val Henderson (9 games). Re-signing them would be a great way to signal championship intent this year. Also on the roster last year: Robyn Jones.

That brings us to the team in question …

Atlanta: The Beat’s keepers were certainly busy last year. Allison Whitworth (11 games) had 67 saves; Ali Lipsher (7 games) had 44. Both have experience elsewhere — Whitworth with Gold Pride as Barnhart’s backup, Lipsher with a lot of starts in Boston. They also have one of the two keepers drafted in 2011, Katie Fraine.

So Atlanta could stick with the corps from last season or perhaps take a run at signing Barnhart or Henderson. But then there are all these other keepers in the mix from magicJack, some of whom might not mind signing with a WPS team this season. …

We can probably rule out Brett Maron (4 games), who played for the Beat in 2010 before Hope Solo’s arrival but has signed overseas. Shannon Myers (1 game) also did time in magicJack’s front office and was pressed into service with two goalkeepers out on World Cup duty.

That leaves three big-time goalkeepers, though we don’t know how much interest they’ll have in WPS:

– Jill Loyden (8 games): Hope Solo’s backup with magicJack (and St. Louis before that) and another contender for the U.S. roster.

Hope Solo (4 games): With magicJack gone, can anyone lure her to play in WPS, or will she work her way back into Olympic shape in residency?

Erin McLeod (not in WPS): Canadian starter ditched magicJack to go overseas. Would she come back?

We’re dealing with a lot of moving pieces here. But given the talent that’s available, it’s hard to imagine any WPS team going into the draft with the intent of starting a rookie goalkeeper all season.

Chris sees Atlanta passing on Henninger to make the glitzier pick of U.S. national camp-dweller Sydney Leroux. Then Sky Blue could pick Henninger out of the No. 2 spot. That might be for the best all around. Henninger can sub for LeBlanc during the Olympics and maybe even push her for the No. 1 spot, especially later in the season.

Now if the Beat pass up Henninger and fail to pick up Loyden, Solo, McLeod, Barnhart or Henderson, that would be a sign of trouble.

I’m guessing that some of these keepers have actually signed without having that news announced, so please check back for updates.

Uncategorized

Myriad most popular: 2011

By popular demand (well, some demand, anyway), I’m going through the stats to see what you read on SportsMyriad this year.

Traffic was down just a little year over year, which isn’t surprising even though the blog didn’t operate all 12 months of 2010. In 2010, I was trying to make this a full-service, revenue-generating blog, so I was posting more frequently. This year, I concentrated a bit more on work that actually pays money.

Still, readership wasn’t bad. Here’s what surprised me:

2012 medal projections keep getting traffic even without recent activity.

The Ultimate Fighter recaps really dropped off. Perhaps that’s because Season 13 wasn’t great.

– Single-Digit Soccer started with a bang and dropped to nothing. That might be the biggest disappointment for me. Some of the posts drew less than 20 page views.

My best MMA writing didn’t do well at all. That included an in-person report on TUF tryouts, my response to a ridiculous Washington Post piece, my take on the media hysteria over an ill-advised kids fight, and the only conference call transcript you’ll ever need.

Here’s what didn’t surprise me:

Angry Duke-bashers were all over my post on the lacrosse scandal. Angry promotion-relegation backers didn’t bother. And when I angered Title IX critics, I had a thoughtful discussion with them but got little traffic.

The WPS-Borislow documents and other breaking news all did pretty well.

Here’s the full list (excluding the posts that drew tiny page views), expressed as percentages of my traffic:

Home page 25.5
WPS WPS and magicJack: Points off the table 5.57
College Former Duke lacrosse players win a couple, lose many 2.83
WPS Dan Borislow statement on WPS suit 2.65
MMA The Ultimate Fighter: Season 13, Episode 6: You’re fired 2.4
WPS Borislow: Reasons WPS is dead, how to save it 1.97
WPS All the Borislow-WPS legal documents (so far) 1.85
WPS The WPS vigil, Dec. 5: What’s Division I, anyway? 1.83
Msoc 1994-2010 World Cup rosters: USA getting better? 1.58
WPS WPS rips Borislow in legal documents 1.13
Wsoc Women’s soccer boom, version 2.0 1.07
WPS Tinkering with the 2012 WPS calendar 1.05
MMA ‘The Ultimate Fighter’: Season 13 cast 0.93
WPS Borislow-WPS suit documents 0.9
MMA The Ultimate Fighter: Season 14, Episode 1 0.85
Wsoc Women’s World Cup: Small step for Japan, giant leap for women’s soccer 0.82
Soccer How and how not to change the U.S. soccer landscape 0.82
Youth Single-Digit Soccer: Sharks, minnows and reasonable goals 0.73
Oly 2012 medal projections 0.71
Soccer A brainstorm on mixing pro and elite amateurs 0.71
MMA The Ultimate Fighter: Season 13, Episode 7: Close shave 0.7
Wsoc Choke! Why there’s no double standard for women’s soccer 0.66
WPS Brainstorming as WPS deadline approaches 0.61
College Student-athletes: Going on the endangered list? 0.61
WPS The WPS vigil: Dec. 2 update 0.61
MMA The Ultimate Fighter: Season 14, Episode 2 0.59
MMA The Ultimate Fighter: Season 13, Episode 9: Shocking end 0.58
Soccer Style points: Why everything you think about the present or future U.S. soccer mentality is wrong 0.57
WPS Will WPS stars sign up for another season? 0.57
Oly 2012 medal projections, men’s track: Bolt, then who? 0.56
Oly 2012 gymnastics: China takes show on the road 0.56
WPS The WPS vigil: Nov. 29 update 0.55
MMA The Ultimate Fighter: Season 13, Episode 8: Not how you shut someone up 0.55
Msoc The marketing of Landon Donovan 0.53
MMA The Ultimate Fighter: Season 13, Episode 5: Agent Cope 0.5
MLS A realistic 2011 MLS season preview 0.49
Wsoc Reflections on “The Man Watching” and Anson Dorrance 0.48
MMA The Ultimate Fighter: Season 14, Episode 5: Bisping’s bad, he’s bad, you know it 0.47
Oly 2012: Field events 0.46
Wsoc Could D.C. fans find Freedom in W-League? 0.45
WPS The WPS vigil: Nov. 30 update 0.45
Soccer Great time for promotion/relegation fans to step up 0.45
Oly 2012 canoe/kayak: Hail Slovakia and Hungary 0.44
MMA ‘The Ultimate Fighter’ tryouts and the soul of MMA fighters 0.44
MMA UFC 136 and my love/hate relationship with MMA 0.41
WPS WPS vs. the semipros 0.39
General Are sports monopolies necessary? 0.38
General What it takes to make a pro women’s sport work 0.38
General Midweek Myriad: Fretting over Freddy, winter winners, soccer challenge 0.38
WPS WPS: It’s pretty much officially not going to be six teams in 2012 0.37
General Gender equity debate won’t end, but can it change? 0.36
MMA The Ultimate Fighter: Season 13, Episode 1: Unlucky 13th 0.35
WPS WPS vigil’s final hours: The overseas question, U.S. budgets 0.34
WPS The Freedom of the Majestic WPS FCs 0.33
WPS Selling WPS tickets in transition (updated) 0.32
Oly 2012 medal projections: Old Cold War battles, Jamaica heat up women’s running 0.32
Msoc Beckham and the remnants of condescending England 0.31
MMA The Ultimate Fighter: Season 14, Episode 4: You know the matchup, but can you stop it? 0.31
Oly 2012 badminton: Any hope for Europe? 0.3
General 2011 in myriad sports 0.3
Oly 2012 men’s swimming: Lochte, Lochte, Phelps, Lochte, Phelps, Phelps … 0.29
MMA The only MMA conference call transcript you’ll ever need 0.29
Oly 2012 women’s swimming and synchro: All about the Franklins 0.27
Oly 2012 pentathlon/triathlon: Modern times 0.27
Oly 2012 track and field projections: Big year for USA? 0.26
Oly 2012 wrestling: Not just an MMA prep course 0.26
Wsoc Fifa World Cup 2011 announces mascot. A cat. An ELEGANT cat 0.26
Soccer The ups and downs of promotion and relegation 0.26
Oly 2012 sailing: Take me away to where I want to be … 0.25
Youth Single-Digit Soccer: The Shin Guardian “treatise” and the fundamentals 0.25
MMA The Ultimate Fighter: Season 13, Episode 2: Bigger upset than VCU 0.25
Cricket My fractured relationship with Ian Bell 0.24
Oly 2012 diving: Can we just say “China” and move on? 0.24
Oly 2012 cycling: The wheels on the bike go round and round 0.23
MLS MLSSoccer.com “Ramos Project” looks promising 0.23
Oly 2012 weightlifting: Only the strong survive 0.23
Oly 2012 fencing: My name is Inigo Montoya … 0.23
Oly 2012 shooting: Bang, bang, bang on the door, baby 0.22
General The effect of arguments 0.21
MMA The Ultimate Fighter: Season 14, Episode 10: A punchy farewell to Spike 0.21
WPS Mad about the Freedom? Place the blame on … 0.2
General Rugby terms: Or why most people who say “scrum” are wrong 0.2
Oly 2012 judo: No chops allowed 0.19
MMA The Ultimate Fighter: Season 13, Episode 10: The finalists are … 0.19
Wsoc Germany 5: Welcome to Heidelberg, Beau! 0.19
Oly 2012 taekwondo: Slightly more violent than Riverdance 0.19
MMA ‘The Ultimate Fighter’: Season 12, Episode 1: Fight! (x14) 0.19
MMA Washington Post piece lectures kids about evils of MMA 0.18
MMA The Ultimate Fighter: Season 14, Episode 7: Ground and … hey! Hold still! 0.18
Oly 2012 rowing: More medals for sitting British athletes 0.18
Wsoc Germany 4: Stuck inside of Frankfurt with the Augsburg blues again 0.18
Soccer What makes a soccer game change? Besides Messi 0.18
Oly 2012 ball sports: Yay, team! Except you folks with bats 0.18
Youth Single-Digit Soccer: Do small-sided games backfire? 0.18
Oly 2012 boxing: Welcome, women! 0.18
MLS MLS All-Stars, overreaction and reaction 0.17
MMA The Ultimate Fighter: Season 14, Episode 3: Dodson the Mole? 0.17
Youth Single-Digit Soccer: Can youth soccer be an afterschool program? 0.16
Soccer Book review: ‘A Beautiful Game’ 0.16
Wsoc Germany 6: Last legs 0.15
MMA Sanchez-Kampmann: MMA judges, statistics and damn lies 0.15
WPS 2011 WPS predictions 0.15
General Friends, athletes, objectivity and professionalism (SEO adds: MMA and sex) 0.15
Oly 2012 tennis/table tennis: Who’s your Venus? 0.14
General Midweek Myriad: Marta, Nadal, handball, 1260s, etc. 0.14
WPS WPS welcomes the sound of sponsors in Season 2 0.14
MMA The Ultimate Fighter: Season 13, Episode 4: Underestimate this 0.14
MLS MLS Cup: An experiment 0.14
MMA The case for Mayhem Miller 0.14
Soccer Best reads on FIFA/CONCACAF crisis 0.13
Soccer The Frimpong questions 0.13
Oly Amateur boxers: Are you looking at my headgear? 0.13
MMA Union opens up in fight against the UFC 0.13
Cricket Ashes ‘old guys’ ready to return to action 0.13
MMA The curse of Fedor: Former opponents faring poorly 0.13
Youth Single-Digit Soccer: When do you split the kids? 0.13
Wsoc Germany 2: Leaving Berlin, never easy 0.13
College The Atlantic, the NCAA and the wrong discussion 0.12
Oly Live: Diamond League debut 0.12
MLS The annual MLS playoff fretting 0.12
MMA ‘The Ultimate Fighter’: Season 11, Episode 1: 14-fight whirlwind 0.11
Soccer World Cup economics and skepticism 0.11
MMA Kids in the cage: How not to do mixed martial arts 0.1
Oly 2012 equestrian: Horse is a horse, of course 0.1
General Myriad most popular 0.1
MMA ‘The Ultimate Fighter’: Season 11, Episode 3: Not that there’s anything wrong with that 0.1
MMA The Ultimate Fighter: Season 13, Episode 3: Turning points 0.1
Wsoc Thunderstruck: D.C. United Women’s home debut 0.1
MMA MMA and drug testing: The good without the bad? 0.1
Soccer Tales of soccer survival: MISL’s Milwaukee Wave 0.1
MLS Is MLS too physical? 0.09
Wsoc Germany: Day 1-2 0.09
MMA The Ultimate Fighter: Season 14, Episode 9: Efficient, yes, but exciting? 0.09
MMA Sort-of review: McCarthy/Hunt, “Let’s Get It On” 0.08
Wsoc Germany 3: Bochum’s bad rap 0.08
Oly The biggest non-Olympic Olympic sports event is upon us … 0.08
Youth Single-Digit Soccer: Position papers 0.08
Youth Single-Digit Soccer: OK, let’s back up a bit … 0.08
MMA The Ultimate Fighter: Episode 14, Season 8: Fire extinguishers! Near-KOs! 0.07
MMA ‘The Ultimate Fighter,’ Season 12, Episode 7: Kos gets a break, or three 0.07
MMA ‘The Ultimate Fighter’: Season 12, Episode 2: Bruce Decoy 0.07
Oly 2012 update: Track and field 0.07
MLS Virtual Viewing Party: MLS All-Star Game 0.07
MLS MLS fans: Shut the *&^&# up 0.07
WPS Freedom’s misfortunes touch Gold Pride, too 0.06
Youth Single-Digit Soccer: Hey! Get out of the woods! 0.06
Oly 2012 projections at the halfway point 0.06
MLS A modest MLS playoff proposal 0.06
Youth Single-Digit Soccer: “Boot it!” 0.06
MMA UFC in transition as it debuts on Fox 0.06
WPS Maron’s world tour: Loans to Africa, teams in Iceland and Sweden, then Atlanta 0.05
MMA A farewell to Fedor? Plus other Strikeforce thoughts 0.05
Msoc Alejandro Bedoya, stealth marketing and the U.S. World Cup roster 0.05
Chess Why this world chess championship is so exciting 0.05
General Here comes the judge … 0.05
Oly LaShawn Merritt, male enhancement and unanswered questions 0.05
MLS MLS Week 6: How long can Red Bulls’ surge last before crash? 0.05
Uncategorized

SportsMyriad in 2012: Keep me in your RSS reader

Through it’s 21-month existence, SportsMyriad has seen erratic activity — flurries of posts, then very little. I’d expect the first couple of months of 2012 to veer toward “very little.” I really need to sit down and wrap up my next book, and I may still have a few features for espnW along with the occasional sports culture post at Popdose.

But please keep me in your RSS readers (or at least follow me on Twitter) for the following reasons:

1. If some news breaks in WPS, I’m still likely to have some of it here.

2. When I get back to business here, I’ll be really revved up to go. Have to update all those 2012 medal projections, you know.

Happy New Year to all in whatever sports you enjoy.

soccer

WPS vs. the semipros

We’ve all lived ten days since I last posted about WPS and nine days since WPS owners accepted U.S. Soccer’s terms for Division I sanctioning, and yet the debate doesn’t seem to have changed.

One reason it’s still going: We’ve seen a return from hibernation from the blogger known as Fake Sigi. (He’s a bit different from the typical “Fake” or “Not” identities that parody Sepp Blatter, Dan Borislow, “soccerreform” and Grant Wahl in that we know his real name and he spends little time mimicking his namesake.)

I’ve seen Fake at the same table as Canadian journalist Duane Rollins, but they still get pretty annoyed with each other. Duane felt compelled to respond to Fake’s post as well as former Whitecaps player Ciara McCormack, who has written one more post arguing directly with Duane and another that mentions the dispute in passing.

So far, though, we haven’t heard anything from the Whitecaps. They’re the ones called “vicious pimps” in Fake’s piece, so you’d think they’d be the most offended party.

But underneath the occasionally amusing insults, we have a fairly legitimate debate. Duane isn’t the only person suggesting that the top North American women’s league should follow more of a semipro model. Peter Wilt, who qualifies as a co-founder of WPS for his work with the Chicago Red Stars, put forth a detailed proposal and sparked an enlightening discussion. Bonnie D. Ford made similar points at espnW and drew a few hostile comments as well as the typical Internet gaggle of juvenile responses.

Here’s the strange part to me: Why are we having this discussion now?

Last year, when the Washington Freedom went up for sale, the Chicago Red Stars self-relegated and FC Gold Pride joined the ranks of the disappeared, the discussion would’ve been timely. This year, all six teams were willing to return — one was told “no thanks” for reasons other than finances. And for the first time in U.S. women’s history, a league was around to absorb a big bump after a big event — one that has much more impact than the World Cup has on MLS.

We’ll have to see how much of that impact carries over into 2012. But here’s the question I haven’t seen addressed: If five ownership groups are willing to gamble on that, why tell them you’d rather go ahead and start the transition to a semipro, scaled-back league now?

On Twitter, I compared the WPS-vs.-semipro debate to 1993, when U.S. Soccer chose between MLS, the existing APSL (A-League) and the rule-bending League One America proposal to leap into the Division I men’s soccer void. They opted for MLS, which was in many senses a leap of faith. It’s easy to say now that men’s soccer is popular in the USA and Canada today. It wasn’t so easy to predict such popularity back in 1993.

I got this response from @DCUWomen:

In 93, men were playing catch up to the world with huge $$ reward a draw… Women is dif biz, needs lower budgets, more teams.

I can see the lower budgets — no one, not even the free-spending Dan Borislow, is suggesting that WPS teams should start shelling out $3 million to $13 million per team like MLS teams did in 2011. But why more teams?

So that’s two questions: Why does WPS need more teams (more than the eight U.S. Soccer is demanding by 2014), and why should the powers that be insist on going semipro if at least eight owners are willing to play legitimate D1 ball by 2014? Anyone have answers?

soccer

WPS vigil’s final hours: The overseas question, U.S. budgets

The U.S. Soccer board will go into a conference call this evening to discuss Topic A in the U.S. women’s soccer community: Will WPS get a waiver to continue as a Division I league with five teams?

Don’t expect any board members to chat openly before that meeting, but in the meantime, we’re getting some interesting conversation that relates at least indirectly to the concept of professional women’s soccer:

The Whitecaps’ white hat knocked off? Canadian writer Duane Rollins chatted with Vancouver Whitecaps exec Bob Lenarduzzi recently and confirmed that the Caps aren’t interested in WPS at the moment. Rollins concluded that if the Whitecaps were turning down WPS, perhaps something is wrong with WPS.

Irish-Canadian player Ciara McCormack fired back a response that made other journalists (well, me, anyway) wince in terror. She has had a couple of stints with the Whitecaps and takes issue with the notion that they’re committed to the women’s game or should be considered any sort of bellwether on WPS’s viability. (I’ve asked the club for a response and will post it as soon as I get one.)

McCormack and Rollins have continued a polite but firm discussion about his reporting. I took issue with the shots at Rollins initially (disclaimer: I know him from MLS circles), protesting that he couldn’t have known that the Whitecaps were anything other than a model women’s team that had a lot of terrific players. (One quibble: I don’t think “just a blogger” applies to Rollins. He’s a journalist. And since so much of the best reporting on women’s soccer takes place on blogs — All White Kit, Equalizer, etc. — I don’t see that as a meaningful distinction in the first place.)

But that disagreement has led us all to a larger issue, which McCormack raises: Let’s start talking openly about the conditions of the women’s game. We’ve seen a wall of silence in women’s soccer this year — players who used to be open with the media have been guarded and even cliched, and no one’s willing to talk about the astounding case of Dan Borislow.

Which leads to this curious case:

No peace in Perth: Two international players left the W-League (Australia)’s Perth Glory soon after Sydney FC beat the club 11-0, a score that has never, ever been approached in WPS play. The initial story was that Norway’s Lisa Marie Woods and New Zealand’s Emma Kete were sacked “for the benefit of overall team harmony” after some sort of incident.

Woods and Kete released a joint statement acknowledging that they had a heated argument in their shared living quarters but denied that they had a physical altercation. And they didn’t appreciate their demeanor being questioned. The club apologized, adding this: “We acknowledge that there may be a somewhat disparity between the culture and professionalism of the W-League and what you may have been used to in Europe and that on the pitch and at training you have acted professionally and given it your all.”

How professional is Europe? From a BigSoccer discussion, I was directed to a couple of entertaining reads on how much money players are making in Europe — both in French. At this point, French soccer in particular seems to have a couple of fully professional teams and some that are nowhere near. If you’re looking for an underdog story, consider Juvisy, which leads Lyon in the current French standings despite operating on less than 10% of Lyon’s budget.

The tips came from a BigSoccer reader who goes by “Katreus,” whose Twitter feed is a recommended follow. Also from Katreus comes this shocker:

Pro women’s soccer in Los Angeles! Ali Riley, Christen Press, Rebecca Moros, Sarah Huffman, Jen Buczkowski, Tina DiMartino, Val Henderson and other WPS veterans — all on the same team? Yes indeed. This makeshift squad will apparently play Mexico and Trinidad/Tobago in friendlies in January. They also have really ambitious plans for 2012, trying to bring Sweden, Canada and Mexico to California for a December tournament.

And they apparently scrimmaged against the U.S. women’s team recently. Here’s some footage. The U.S. defense might want to watch that counterattack.

Safe to say I’m looking into this. If you have more info, please share.

The petition drive. Former Boston Breakers exec Andy Crossley isn’t impressed with the WPS petition drive or the idea that women’s soccer should be sold as a “cause.” I don’t think Andy — who has already shared plenty of WPS info in his piece on FC Gold Pride and his interviews with former Gold Pride exec Ilisa Kessler and player/journalist Tiffany Weimer — would object to me saying his piece raises more questions than answers.

One thing I’ve kicked around in my head: Many sports teams are owned out of affectations. Russian moguls lavish luxuries on women’s basketball players. Barcelona’s finances are questionable. Plenty of American sports teams lose money. And some — from Manchester City to magicJack — are essentially loss leaders for companies.

Given that, I don’t think it’s unreasonable to reach out to the Ellens and Oprahs of the world. Ellen DeGeneres has a show to advertise. Oprah has a fledgling cable network that needs to advertise. If one of them were to buy a WPS team and operate it for roughly the same money that Puma spent each of the past three years to equip WPS teams and then have stores that don’t even offer soccer gear, would that be such a bad investment?

And for many fans, petitions are all they can do. It’s not reasonable to ask someone in Seattle to buy Sky Blue season tickets. That fan can only support the league by watching games and possibly buying merchandise.

So maybe instead of U.S. Soccer requiring a season-ticket drive, it should require a merchandise drive? Get all 45,000-plus signees to buy a T-shirt?

It’s moot at this point, anyway. The call is due to start in less than an hour. We might hear nothing tonight, or U.S. Soccer could just punt a decision once again. Or the next few hours could be the most important in league history.

soccer

WPS: It’s pretty much officially not going to be six teams in 2012

The reason given for the delay in WPS sanctioning was to give the league time to line up a sixth team.

That has not happened. Here’s WPS CEO Jennifer O’Sullivan:

While our discussions with expansion candidates continue to be positive, we are now at a point in time where adding a team for 2012 at this late date could put the club at a great disadvantage both in a business and competitive sense. We are moving forward in planning the 2012 season with the current field of five teams that are committed to play in the League and continuing expansion discussions for 2013.

So O’Sullivan and company have been making the case to U.S. Soccer’s Pro League Task Force that the league should be sanctioned in 2012. Not much comment about those discussions beyond this, also from O’Sullivan:

While we won’t comment in detail about our ongoing discussions with U.S. Soccer, we can say our meeting on Tuesday with U.S. Soccer regarding the sanctioning of WPS for 2012 was productive. Discussions will continue and we’re hopeful to have an opportunity next season to build upon the league’s strong momentum, both on and off the field.

Also today, U.S. women’s national team captain Christie Rampone did a Twitter chat on the U.S. Soccer WNT feed. She likes to sew, wants to be remembered as someone who led by example, treasures her fitness and prefers chemistry to biology. She did not address WPS.

Other WPS-related reads:

– GOOD suggests women’s sports should be run as a charity, not as a business. That’s an unfortunate choice of words (“degrading,” said at least one sane person on Twitter), but the notion of subsidizing a sport isn’t unusual. It’s done in other sports all the time, but it’s usually a bit more subtle than saying “charity.” (For a contrasting view, see the espnW piece that former WNBA president Val Ackerman wrote in October.)

– A couple of us have reported for a while that the Vancouver Whitecaps weren’t planning to leap into WPS as it currently stands. This Canadian Soccer News interview goes into more detail.

soccer

Great time for promotion/relegation fans to step up

Because I wrote a book about Major League Soccer that sold at least 10 copies and long held a position in which USA TODAY tolerated a small amount of soccer writing, I’m something of a lightning rod for what we might call “promotion/relegation zealotry.”

The funny thing is that these folks don’t say, “Hey, you’ve done a lot of painstaking and not particularly profitable research on the business of American soccer — let’s talk about what would need to happen to make a traditional league system work in this country.” These folks insist on yelling at me and ignoring what I have to say in response, as if I’m completely ignorant of the issues but would have the power to push their cause forward if I’d only adopt their slogans. People don’t do this in MMA — I’ve never had people yell at me to say, “Admit it — you’re part of the coverup to keep the UFC from adopting a tournament format!” In soccer, I’m not alone in this — every once in a while on Twitter, you see another soccer journalist say, “Enough. I’ve tried to be reasonable, and now I’m blocking you.”

Every once in a while (and it happened in the past week), someone’s reasonable about it. But more typically, I draw people who think (A) promotion/relegation should happen now or (B) there is an active conspiracy to prevent promotion/relegation from happening.

The simple fact is this — to my knowledge and to the knowledge of other journalists and soccer scholars,  no one has ever put forward a plan to put capital behind a promotion/relegation system. You can’t vote “yay” or “nay” on something that doesn’t exist.

Soccer leagues of the past certainly weren’t lining up to mimic the English way. David Wangerin’s must-read Soccer in a Football World tells us about owners of 1920s and 1930s who came from other sports and sometimes resisted putting their “major league” clubs in the same Cup competitions. The NASL pretty much didn’t even bother with the Open Cup, and it had quite a few gimmicky rules. And yet its “closed system” and Americanized game didn’t prevent a flood of investors, including quite a few English and European folks, from jumping in with both feet.

The reality is that promotion/relegation has simply never been on the table. If you don’t have 20 or more teams lined up and ready to go, there’s not much point. And when we’re still facing the reality of a successful MLS team (D.C. United) unable to make a deal with any of the quirky municipalities in its metro area to get a stadium built, we can’t say we have the facilities in place, either.

But remember, we’re dealing with conspiracy theorists here. So when you raise these arguments, you’re just part of the conspiracy. And you get asked questions like “I don’t understand why non-MLS shareholders work so hard to defend model which blocks more investment in the American game.” (Well, MLS teams now have a few Designated Players spots to use, teams can develop Home-Grown Players through youth academies, Toronto is spending $20 million on a youth facility, and Kansas City’s ownership has revitalized a moribund MLS market with great marketing, a good team and a beautiful stadium, so … what investment is being blocked?)

That usually leads to every criticism of MLS, just or unjust, being laid at your doorstep as if it’s your fault. Or that all of these problems would be magically fixed by waves of moneyed investors if U.S. Soccer would simply force a promotion/relegation scheme into existence even though no one has made a proposal for such a league (and certainly didn’t back in 1993, when MLS was the winner among the three bids to bring Division I soccer back from the dead in the United States).

And it doesn’t matter if you believe on a personal level that it’d be really cool if the USA had a promotion/relegation system, in part because it would mean that a lot of logistical hurdles and cultural antipathy had been overcome. I wouldn’t stop following MLS if it suddenly went pro/rel, and I think most fans would stick around. (At the league level, at least — demoted teams tend to lose a little bit at the gate.)

Anyway, the point isn’t to rehash what I’ve said before or what keeps going around BigSoccer (coincidentally, a great summary was posted on Tuesday). It’s tempting to do a thorough list of promotion/relegation myths akin to anti-creationism sites like TalkOrigins.

Here’s the point: Promotion/relegation fanatics have a golden opportunity to step forward. In women’s soccer.

As of today, WPS is awaiting word on Division I sanctioning for 2012. Regardless of whether that goes through, 2013 might be wide open. WPS likely will need some expansion to maintain sanctioning for 2013.

If someone wants to present an alternate plan for a soccer league based on promotion/relegation, now is the time.

So there you have it. Want promotion/relegation? Convinced investors would be more likely to go for that than the U.S. model? Great! Let’s see it.

mma

The only MMA conference call transcript you’ll ever need

(Classical music fades in and out as if on a distant radio station. It abruptly stops at times, raising hopes that call is about to begin. Then it restarts, dashing those hopes. … 10-15 minutes after the scheduled start time, the music stops.)

MUFFLED VOICE: … then he threw the soup.

(Others laugh)

OPERATOR: This is the UXC 132 conference call. Please hit Star-1 if you want to ask a question, but not yet. If you’re on a speakerphone, please mute it so your signal can reach our equipment. Turning it over to your host now, Mr. Jim Payar.

JIM: Thanks, this is Jim … Pierre … welcoming you to today’s call. On the line, we have UXC welterweight champion Delbert “Wild Man” Grumptalker, UXC heavyweight Pete Oneliner and Grumptalker’s challenger, Silva Silva. Silva will be speaking in Klingon, but we have Ed Worf translating for him. We’re still trying to reach Droopy Napmaster, who’ll be fighting against Oneliner — we’ll let you know when he’s on the line. Operator, we’re ready to take questions now.

OPERATOR: Once again, that’s Star-1 if you want to ask a question. We’ll pause now to assemble the queue.

(20 seconds later)

OPERATOR: Your first question is from Warren Whyzefirst from ChokeMeOut.com

WHYZEFIRST: Yeah, my question is for Droopy. Droopy, you won your last fight using a modified guillotine. Do you …

JIM: Hey … Warren? Warren? Yeah, Droopy isn’t on the line yet.

WHYZEFIRST: Oh. Um, OK then, I’ll ask Pete. Pete, Droopy tends to win his fights using various types of guillotine chokes. What do you plan to do to avoid his guillotine.

ONELINER: Knock him out. Maybe before he gets to the cage.

WHYZEFIRST: OK, great. Um, I’ll come back if Droopy gets on the line.

Continue reading

Uncategorized

The WPS vigil, Dec. 5: What’s Division I, anyway?

http://storify.com/duresport/wps-vigil-dec-5-what-s-division-i-anyway.js?border=false&header=false&sharing=false&more=false

mma

The case for Mayhem Miller

Jason “Mayhem” Miller won the coaching battle with Michael Bisping, hands down. And his attitude during the show compared with Bisping’s made it easy for fans to pick sides going into last night’s fight.

But Miller really didn’t have much of a chance. He hadn’t fought in 16 months, and his last fight was a largely ceremonial dispatching of aging legend Sakuraba. He had only one prior fight in the UFC, in 2005 against Georges St. Pierre. Dana White says he didn’t look too good in that one, but who looks good against GSP? White and some of the media sang Dan Hardy’s praises for the mere act of not being submitted in a five-round whitewash. (Hardy lost his next three fights.)

Miller’s much better on the ground than he is on his feet. Last night, he was fighting a kickboxing monster in Bisping who’s also a bit bigger — Bisping’s a former light heavyweight, Miller sometimes fights at welterweight.

So Miller, rather predictably, came out and had a strong first round (FightMetric stats clearly favor him) but used up all his energy in doing so. Bisping pounded him for another round and a half before the fight was stopped.

White didn’t seem bullish on Miller’s future after last night’s loss. He Tweeted that the fight was one of the most lopsided in UFC history, though it clearly wasn’t the most lopsided of the night. (That would be Johnny Bedford’s gruesome beatdown of Louis Gaudinot in another substantial size mismatch.) Even after getting called out on Twitter by people pointing to Miller’s first-round performance and countless lopsided fights in UFC history (Quarry-Starnes, Silva-Griffin), he stuck by it in his postfight interview with Ariel Helwani. He was even less enthusiastic about Miller in his interview with Heavy MMA.

Four reasons to keep Mayhem in the Octagon:

1. He deserves a shot to be something other than the big underdog. His two UFC fights are against the greatest welterweight of all time and a top contender who’s a bad matchup for him even if he hasn’t been inactive for 16 months. If Hardy gets to stick around after dropping four straight, why cut Miller?

2. Grappling doesn’t suck. Variety is a good thing on a UFC card. The organization has plenty of “stand-and-bang” guys who stick around forever even though they’ll never crack the top 20. How about keeping a guy who can bring it on the ground?

3. He’s a good personality. He could easily join Stephan Bonnar and Amir Sadollah in the rotation of analyst/panelist/interviewers. (And let him do a real entrance next time.)

4. Promotional credibility. Fans tend to notice if you hype somebody up and then dump on them after one mistake.

Mayhem brought a lot to this season of The Ultimate Fighter, and that’s nothing to take lightly. We need to quit pretending that the best fighters are necessarily the best or most compelling TUF coaches. (See Lesnar, Brock. Or Hughes, Matt.) Maybe he has a long way back before he can coach there again, but people would probably tune in.

If Strikeforce continues as the flashy, techno-infused sibling to the rock-and-rap UFC, maybe Mayhem would be a better fit there in the long run. But surely he deserves at least one more shot in the UFC first. He did the UFC a great service by helping them reinvigorate The Ultimate Fighter before it moves to a new network. Seems like he should get some capital out of that valuable service.