pro soccer

A dual thought experiment: 1993 players in 2019 and vice versa

In my conversation with Dan Loney, we somehow wound up talking about the Colorado Foxes and the old APSL/A-League.

Dan made the case that if the 1993 Foxes played in MLS, they would eventually fall off the pace because of a lack of depth and resources, but they would win until that happens.

So that brought to mind two thought experiments …

1. Would the 1993 Colorado Foxes fare well if they were transported into MLS today?

I found 1993 rosters and stats on the old A-League archive, which still exists at Tripod, which still exists.

The Foxes had two goalkeepers splitting time, both of whom wound up in MLS. Mark Dodd fared pretty well down the road. Jim St. Andre had a rough time.

The biggest name on the roster is Robin Fraser, who had a very good MLS career and a lot of meaningful games with the U.S. national team. You may also recognized Tom Soehn, Brian Haynes, Chad Ashton and Mark Santel. (Basically, Foxes coach Dave Dir took a lot of his players with him to the Dallas Burn. Yes, Burn. 1996 was a weird time.)

Top scorers were Scott Benedetti, whom I remember, and Taifour Diane, whom I do not. Ted Eck wasn’t far behind. Diane went to Germany to play for a long time and then go into coaching.

Fraser, Eck and Diane made the All-APSL team.

Now that I look at that roster, I don’t think they would’ve been competitive. But I don’t remember them quite as well as some people might.

The APSL at the time had eight teams, three of them in Canada. The year before, it had five teams, all in the USA. The next year, the APSL added the Seattle Sounders. (The Montreal Impact were already in the league.)

So that brings us to a second question …

2. What would MLS teams look like if we only had eight teams?

Let’s assume 10 or so American players are in Europe, as they were in 1994. At that time, U.S. national teamers who had gone to Europe included John Harkes, Tab Ramos, Eric Wynalda, Roy Wegerle, Juergen Sommer, Frank Klopas, Paul Caligiuri and Mike Lapper. U.S. players who had grown up in Europe and stayed there (until a few years later): Thomas Dooley and Earnie Stewart.

So let’s assume John Brooks and Cameron Carter-Vickers stayed put in Europe. (Or Europe and England, if Brexit goes through.) And let’s assume bright prospects like Christian Pulisic, Tim Weah, Josh Sargent and Weston McKennie are in Europe, along with DeAndre Yedlin, Ethan Horvath, Matt Miazga, Shaq Moore and Eric Lichaj.

Let’s assume the three Canadian teams take eight U.S. players each. The five U.S. teams take 18 U.S. players each, filling the other spots with internationals. That’s 114 U.S. players condensed onto eight teams.

What would that look like?

soccer

Tripping back through soccer-chatting archives

Seems fitting that a new-ish soccer site would launch by paying tribute to the early days of online soccer-gabbing.

That’s exactly what Jason Davis, Trevor Hayward and a new site called Backheel did. And they were nice enough to include my thoughts, along with those of several others who were part of the wild roller-coaster of sharing soccer information and discussion on this newfangled thing called the Internet.

Bruce McGuire, the man behind the DuNord blog and its terrific daily news wrap, has long called soccer “the sport of the Internet.” And there’s no doubt the Internet gave soccer a huge boost. (I’ve covered two sports that thrived in new media — soccer and MMA. Coincidentally, Bruce is also a fan of both.)

The old North American Soccer mailing list was full of lively and occasionally pointed discussions. But it was also a clearinghouse for information you weren’t likely to get elsewhere. If you wanted a report on an A-League game, you weren’t likely to find one unless the local paper had (A) an interest in covering its local team and (B) a fully functional website. Thanks to NAS, you’d have one waiting in your inbox with a subject line like “NAS Carolina-Rochester (R) – another brawl breaks out.”

From there, people branched out. They formed independent news sites, trying to fill the void in coverage on events like the U.S. Open Cup. They flocked to BigSoccer, where a lot of us spent our Saturday mornings giving each other updates on European games with U.S. players. (Hey, Joe-Max is getting in the game for Everton!) Some of us working at smaller papers got jobs at bigger papers and started sneaking more and more soccer coverage onto the websites.

And this was itself a branch of rec.sport.soccer, which had compiled a simple and comprehensive archive of global results that’s still up on the web in its 1995-HTML glory.

We also had a wonderful sense of serendipity. Look at the topics covered on a typical day in 1995: A-League results and tables (including one in 3-1-0 format, which the league wasn’t using), analysis of the U.S. U-23 midfield, a rant on the USISL Boston Storm (with Preston Burpo!), a request to find a bar showing Copa America in Philly, Mexican coaching rumors, etc. Another day has discussion of the as-yet-unnamed New York/New Jersey and Washington MLS teams, the news that Preki had won the CISL’s MVP award, a look ahead to CONCACAF World Cup qualifying, a CISL recap (Dallas Sidekicks drew a league-record 16,427 fans), and this age-old complaint: “If MLS thinks they can sell soccer on artificial turf they are dreaming in technicolor!”

I might be overromanticizing the sense of community we had in those days. We were surely a fractious bunch. We argued about the direction MLS would take and what would happen to the A-League and other then-USL divisions.  But there was a sense that we were all in this together and that a rising tide would lift all boats.

And what I’m not overromanticizing is what a lifeline this was. I could go to Soccernet, which was literally a father-and-son operation at the outset, and check the latest standings in Europe. That, plus the still-indispensable Soccer America, gave me some sense of the context for the broadcast I would hear when I aimed my shortwave radio’s antenna out the window to listen to the BBC.

It’s easy to take everything for granted now. We wake up on the weekends, flip on the TV and listen to Rebecca Lowe hosting NBC’s uber-professional coverage of the Premier League. We have our pick of sites for live scores and lineups. We can dissect games in real time on Twitter. Feedly can scour all of our favorite news sources for the latest stories.

So that community has fractured a bit. Now the East Coasters all hate the smug Cascadians who think they invented soccer supporter culture. MLS isn’t progressing quickly enough for some tastes, and the arguments lead to accusations of self-interest rarely seen this side of the Koch brothers. Everyone thinks he’s the only person in the world who pays attention to the Open Cup and everyone else is out to silence it.

Such things come with progress. And that’s good. MLS would look quite ridiculous playing by the same allocation rules it had in 1996, not to mention the shootout. Lower-division soccer collapsed but is finding its roots again. And the world’s best players are on U.S. TVs almost as often as Spongebob.

The past was fun. The present and future are even better.

mma, soccer, tennis

Friday news: Not all Masters

A few headlines for today; look for a full Weekend Watch later. It’ll be staggering, given all that’s going on in soccer this weekend.

Soccer: Another step forward for the Dynamo’s stadium. Commenters still insisting we shouldn’t believe everything that’s been reported and researched — it’ll all fall on taxpayers, anyway. Yeah, reporting and research are overrated. (Houston Chronicle)

Soccer: Australia’s A-League has earned some praise and a few followers for late-night broadcasts on FSC, but with one club set to stop paying bills and others needing rescue, the head of operations has stepped down. (Sydney Morning Herald)

MMA: You might not have seen it on TV (I believe my first English-language option is NBC’s highlight show a little after 4 a.m. Sunday morning), but Bellator’s second season debuted last night with a solid win for UFC vet Roger Huerta and a survival-mode win for international wrestling vet Joe Warren. (MMA Fighting Stances)

MMA: A judge says fighting pioneer Ken Shamrock must pay the UFC $175,000 in legal fees after losing his lawsuit against the promotion. As Michael David Smith points out at FanHouse, that’s an effective deterrent for the UFC against future lawsuits from fighters, but it’s rather sad for Shamrock, whose fight career has only grown more farcical with each passing year. He’s a UFC Hall of Famer — can he put that status up for sale on eBay? (FanHouse)

Tennis: Kim Clijsters won a big title last week in Miami but had a rough transition to clay-court season, falling to 258th-ranked Beatriz Garcia Vidagany in the Andalucia Open. (AP)

Women’s football: No, not women’s soccer. We’re talking American football, which will have a women’s world championship. Should we contact IOC president Jacques Rogge to tell us the tournament won’t be competitive? The PDF with the roster tells us everyone’s full-time job — a handful of teachers, some physical trainers and at least one attorney. Don’t mess with this group. (USA Football)